24 Hour Customer Service:
1-570-955-1438

Call for a quote line:
1-570-301-7456

Wisely Crafted Institutions Research Papers

The purpose for and means by which a government assumes power has been debated for countless generations. Research papers on wisely crafted institutions explore the institutions within the government that have been well thought out and usually contain an appropriate system of checks and balances. Have Paper Masters assist you with you research on government institutions and the political entities within any nation.

Government has increasingly come under inspection as worldwide systems crumble and are rebuilt in various forms. Our own system has had both adamant supporters and vigorous detractors. While the necessity for some type of government is commonly accepted, the value of government as an institution can be debated.

Many questions regarding the formation, efficiency and effectiveness of different types of government still resound. Most agree that a government is designed to provide order, protection and essential services to the people over which a government presides. It is assumed that government is necessary due to the ills and evil that might threaten an unchecked society. However some question whether governments have the ability to provide anything beyond what the internal structure of the governed would innately provide.

Among the Wisely Crafted Institutionss debated is whether or not wisely crafted institutions can supply that which virtue can not. Before one can answer the thesis it is important to operationally define and understand the premise. Public institutions are not limited to government, but for the interest of this rhetoric, governments will be the focus. Wisely Crafted InstitutionsWisely crafted institutions are those that are painstakingly established with much deliberation on the basis of sound and/or proven reason and practice. Virtue, the subject of ongoing delineation for many philosophers and theologians, is never simply defined. However, commonly accepted definition of virtue refers to innately good and desirable qualities of value and worth, such as morality, integrity, honesty and righteousness. Under these assumptions the question then is whether or not a wisely-crafted government has the potential to provide society with those things that have not been provided by a societal sense of morality, integrity and honesty.

The position laid out by Paper Masters is the following:

  • Wisely-crafted governments do have the potential to provide society with those things that have not been provided by a societal sense of morality, integrity and honesty.
  • Well-crafted governments can supply what virtue can not.
  • There are few examples of government that maximize on this potential.

Virtue should dictate that individuals be moral, honest and reliable in their beliefs and behaviors. In a society that means acting not just in a way that belies personal virtue but in a manner that provides for all citizens communally. However, it is widely recognized that without government people do not unanimously choose to act in a way that promotes good and desirable qualities of value and worth, instead anarchy rules. Because innate virtue is not sufficient to ensure order and peaceable existence, an external system of order is necessary.

When Kant proffers that, “The problem of organizing a state can be solved even for a nation of devils, if only they are intelligent”, he is expressing the underlying principle of government. Even the most abhorrent group of individuals, reocognizing that their own inherent tendency toward vice is self-destructive, can agree to abide by a set of rules that creates an environment that resembles one run according to virtue. In this way the government supplies the constructive framework that is lacking in an individual’s perception or inclination.

Winthrop certainly supported this notion in On Liberty. As a matter of fact Winthrop challenged man’s natural liberty in favor of an artificially regulated federal or civil liberty. He noted that natural liberty included both an individual’s choices to do good, in essence virtuous deeds, and evil, or non-virtuous deeds. More simply this means that people are not innately disciplined to choose only behaviors that are good and virtuous for themselves and society. Meanwhile Winthrop declared that liberty as an object of authority, in this case government, is not so limited and therefore can remain good, just and honest. More simply this means that government, as an objective force, can require that individuals choose and maintain only behaviors that are good and virtuous for themselves and society.

This belief is what supports the government development and enforcement of laws and standards of behavior. An individual’s personal code might vaguely define behaviors such as murder and theft, while a government can provide common definition and laws that prohibit violent acts. While individuals might choose to pay their employees substandard wages and force children to work in unsafe conditions and waylay the environment, a government can enforce honorable and just behavior. While individuals might not be prompted to provide for their neighbors who are ill, poor or uneducated, a government can provide those things that by virtue should be available to all people.

Publius, Federalist Paper #10 written by James Madison in support of large republican democracy also supports the fact that wisely-crafted institutions can provide what virtue can not. Madison remarks that in a representative republic, more than other forms of government, the combined voice projected through representatives is more representative of the public good than what individuals proclaim in their own voices. Meaning that an person’s innate virtue does not provide the necessary requisites for maintaining a society that are supported by a representative group. According to Madision, large representative republics also protect against an individual or small group coming to power who might promote their own selfish goals and interests over that of society as a whole. This again supports the fact that individuals cannot be relied upon to consistently do the right thing and therefore an objective institution is necessary to supply what virtue lacks.

Some people argue that wisely-crafted institutions, namely government, cannot provide what virtue can not. However, the potential for government to do so is supportable. Government can bring out the common interests of all people and support them above personal interests. Government can implement standards of conduct and laws that require individuals to choose behaviors that are good for themselves and society. It stands to reason, therefore, that government can provide society with those things that have not been provided by a societal sense of morality, integrity and honesty, in essence supplying what virtue can not. The greatest support for detractors of this notion is that, while government has the potential to provide these things, it does not always succeed.

Even those most ardent supporters of a government imposed virtue present evidence on the difficulty in maintaining such as system. In A Model of Christian Charity, Winthrop recognizes that, for a society to work, everyone must bind together in joined affection and depend upon each other, and give up something individual for the common good. If the government were to fail to provide for a commonly held belief of good, it would not succeed. In addition, individuals, while in agreement to join a collective government for their benefit might need to be coerced into maintaining the framework of shared virtue. While Kant realized that the group of intelligent devils could figure out a system, it is doubtful that individuals in that collective would conform without ongoing obligation to do so. If a government fails to require individuals to maintain the commonly help belief of good, it would also fail.

Government is designed to provide order, protection and essential services to the people over which a government presides, combating the ills and evils that might threaten an unchecked society. Government has the potential to supply that which virtue can not. Government can promote the common good and implement standards of conduct and law that achieve a social environment that virtue alone cannot promote. It is true that individuals must first be prompted to unite under a government and then be induced to maintain the belief in the common good. Many governments fail to do this, but that does not change the fact that well crafted institutions do have the potential to supply what virtue can not.

Related Research Paper Topics

Ideal Government research papers explore two views of an ideal government, one by Karl Marx and the other by Niccolo Machiavelli.

Philanthropic Organizations Research Papers look at the history of the different charity institutions.

John Dewey's Influence on American Education Research Papers explore the impact and the philosophy about education and his institutions.

American Civil Liberties Union custom research papers discuss the nonpartisan, nonprofit organization that focuses on freedom of speech issues and has expanded its size and scope over the decades.

Individuals and Societies Research Papers look at the interactions between these two entities and that accounts many of the behaviors and actions of humanity.

Classical Liberalism - Research papers on the classical liberal view find that the individual and state have an interdependent relationship, based on mutual trust, mutual benefits, the systematic exchange of function and goods, and justice.

Immanuel Kant provides an excellent foundation for a research paper on ethics.

Kant and Utilitarianism Research Papers look at a sample of an order placed for a comparison between two philosophical approachs.

Utilitarianism research papers discuss John Stuart Mill's idea of morals based on utility.

Beliefs, Values, and Morals Application Research Papers delve into an order placed on the philosophical and theoretical foundations of personal beliefs.

Beyond Good and Evil research papers discuss the book by Nietzsche.

Moral Issues in Society Research Papers examine an order placed on if certain institutions should practice the affirmative action.

Cultural Norms research papers discuss the norms that become the product of a cultures traditions, values and customs.

Socialization of Women Research Papers examine the varied ways women are socialized from one culture to the next.

Study of Human Behavior research papers discuss the study that focuses on several of the social sciences, principally psychology, sociology, economics, and anthropology.

The Social Contract was written by Rousseau in 1762 in response to the political theory that citizens enter into an unwritten contract with each other to lift each other out of their primitive state and establish government for the general will and good of the people.

States' Rights - States' Rights research paper discuss the constitutional issue usually denoted by the phrase “states’ rights,” i.e. the power relationship between state governments and the federal government.

Analyze the Anti-Federalist Argument - Be sure to read Federalist papers #10 and #51, and, of course, Anti-Federalist paper #17.

Local Government Finance - Local Government Research Papers discuss the management policies in local government finance.

Capitalism and Government - A Capitalism and Government research paper attempts to discuss the relationship between an economic system, capitalism, and government. 

Representative Democracy - Representative Democracy Research Papers on a political science topic.